Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Depression for 2 yrs Is Taking It's Toll.
Power Surge Forums > Board Discussions > Depression (Menopause Related) / Anti-depressants / The Blues / Sadness
Pages: 1, 2
Idie
I didn't think it could get any worse....we'll it can. I have recently determined after 2 years of suffering and trying multiple things that this is not going to get better. To top it off my daughter graduated from high school and my father died all within 2 weeks. I'm feeling like I'm losing everything.  It has been a long summer and I am so tired of it all------I'm starting to forget the person I once was. These days I find myself putting one foot in front of the other and just getting through the days. The strangest thing for me is that I don't feel much of anything anymore----I liked it better when I felt happiness, laughter and even sadness but for the last 2 years it has been just feelings of disconnect and misery.  Boy, I really sound pathetic don't I?? Am I the only one who is experiencing this?? I've taken everything from soy to natural hormones, birth control pills, all the alternatives, vitamins, St. John's Wart, DHEA, and so on and so on.  From reading these boards, I see a lot of people searching for help but not very many finding it. The boards do serve as a place to get support---much like a counseling forum---that is good. I'm so disappointed to know that the medical world has really done women a disservice by not getting this figured out.
jeanne
Hi Idie,Sorry you have been so miserable. It sure can take a long time for this stuff to even out. How old are you , and how long have you been going through menopause? I felt much the same way for quite a long time till I became postmeno and things started calming down. Have you been to see about any kind of anti-depressant? I know not everyone takes to them , but many do and it just might help . Maybe a trip to the doc to ask about them? Otherwise I'm sure you know all the ways that can help , and maybe have even tried most of them. But one I know helps is helping others by volunteering for schools , hospitals, nursing homes, wheels on meals, whatever your community and you find most appealing. Hey, it's worth a shot. Even if you have to drag yourself the first few times , it does make you feel good when someone looks at you so gratefully:)You aren't losing everything, sweetie, you are just in menopause with grief thrown into the whole mess. Give yourself time. I know 2 years sounds like a lot , but it will pass , Honest! I would never , never lie about that. I'm 57 and it's nowhere near as it bad anymore. Please come here to talk more often , that helps too. We all are in the same shaky boat heading for calmer waters . hugs, jeanne
Janel
hi Idie, Oh boy do I know how you feel, menopause is hard enough and then everything else on top of it. I lost my Mother and sister 6 months apart and its not easy. Yes I have gotten support here but I have also found answers.Its not as if none of us find what works for us because we do. Some find natural works, other are on HRT, SSIs work for some. All of that is shared here so that we can find answers. Dont give up trying, as Dearest once told me "You have to reach down inside yourself and find HOPE" it really is there, sometimes we just have to look harder smile.gif You will find it and along with it you will find answers. Hugs Janel
EileenG
Idie,For me, Zoloft helped me  get over a really rough time.  I know not everyone can take antidepressants (its the only one that I could tolerate without side-effects).  I now can deal with the things I need/want to deal with.  Saying that, I just want to reassure you that there is a time in our lives -now- when we re-evaluate everything.  It takes enormous energy to do this --- so, we feel kind of wrung out emotionally and physically.  You will get through this!  Come to the boards for emotional support, ok?  These ladies are just the best!  Everyone truly cares how you're doing and we all need to hear how you're tackling your meno-challenges.  In this way, you help us too.  Lots of hugs to you, Idie.  
SylvryMoon
Dear Idie,When things look darkest, remember that we are all here to hold your hand until you are strong enough to stand on your own.  The other women had wonderful answers.  I, too, encourage you to see a doctor about an anti-depressant.  They are not "feel-good" pills, they merely block certain mood enhancing chemicals in the brain from getting reabsorbed into the system.  In other words, those natural chemicals, which we all have in our bodies, have a chance to stay there and circulate to make us feel better.  I had a terrible reaction to Prozac, but Effexor works well for me.  Zoloft works well for Eileen.  So something will work well for Idie.

Talk, talk, talk.  If you can't see a therapist, then use these boards to talk about what's bothering you.  We may not be able to help like a therapist can, but we can listen and empathize.

Most importantly, have faith that "this too shall pass."  Menopause is a time of jumbled emotions and highly charged feelings.  So don't be afraid to reach out to us - we're here for you.Hugs,

IreneCrites
Dear Idie...There is nothing I can add that the other gals have not said except to welcome you and encourage you to keep coming and posting.  There are answers for all of us it just takes time to find them sometimes.  This is not an easy passage of time for some Meno gals but you will receive much support here  as well as volumes of information collected over seven plus years and unending research by Dearest.You will find the inner strength to move through this and in the interim please let us help you.  Be well and I look forward to your continued presence on this site.
Idie
Thanks everyone----your responses were overwhelming and oh...sooooo appreciated. Today is a particularily bad day. I've tried Prozac...no luck just made me sick to my stomach everyday. I think I'm just worn out from trying to find something, anything that will help. Maybe the Biest isn't enough. I know that this sounds strange but if I do have a "better" day it usually happens just before I get my period.....around day three I start feeling bad again and it starts all over again. *****Sigh*****
HSpec
Idie,I can totally relate to what you are going through. As the other girls have said, we have all had the kinds of experiences that you are now having. For me it was my dad and mom passing, my husband critically ill and then me. I thought for soooooooooo long that things would never end and my depression was here to stay. I went into therapy and started to re-evaluate my life, focusing on the positives. It has helped. The fact that you have joined us is a great way to get help. I know that at times it feels like there will be no end, but there will be sunshine in your life again. Focus with pride on the accomplishments of your daughter. My son graduated from high school in '98. I thought I was losing him too. Guess what, he comes home (with laundry of course), phones, etc. You are still a big part of her life and will always be. No, they don't need us the same way they did when they were younger, but they do still need us. Idie, you will get through this.Feel the hugs I am sending your way.H
mrsmunro0510
Hi Ladies..

Reading these encourage posts is helpful. I hope you are feeling better soon, Idie.  

In the last year, I divorced, remarried, moved 2500 miles away from my home of 43 years. Miss my 2 kids like crazy. I've been hospitalized once for depression.On a new drug called Geodon (anyone heard of it yet?).Anyway, the edge of despair has passed, but I still get through the day with the sensation of barely having a grip, and often on the verge of panic. And I am starting a new job next week?? lol

Heidi

EileenG
Heidi,I too, have my ups and downs even with the depression being under control.  For me, Zoloft was a miracle drug.  I know that it hasn't been for others -- I have tried so many with TERIBLE side effects before I found this one.  I have always had depression -- even as a kid (never diagnosed -just got the label of being "too sensitive") During any kind of hormonal upheaval it gets worse.  It also is worse with any kind of trauma (like going to the dentist-- I'm not kidding).  I seem to have a short supply of serotonin that has to be balanced out again after anything too stimulating happens! :sad:   I can only imagine what you're going through with all the changes in your life!!  I'm so glad you've found us here on Power-Surge.  We need to hear from you so that we can all keep learning about your experience with this time in your life.   I can't remember who said it but someone was saying that having depression is like being born without a filter.  You take in everything that other people with the filter just shut out.  That seems so true to me!
mrsmunro0510
Eileen,

Thank you for sharing, and I am happy to hear that Zoloft was so effective for you.  Are you on anything else at this time? I also had great results with Zoloft for several years, at one time the Dr. had me up to 200 mg./day.   But in time it didn't seem to be effective, and in retrospect, I would know for sure the problem with depression became the result of hormonal deficiency. You're right, when there's been a substantial history of depression, it gradually becomes more clear that we are transitioning into something more complex than major depression. It's not only serotonin reuptake inhibitors that we need. Someone mentioned on this board that it's likely to take a while to find the correct HRT combination. My Dr. here put me on an oral contraceptive. I have heard that OC is actually stronger than other forms of hormone replacement and/or naturally compounded hormones. The trick is to find a Dr. who cares to listen women. They seem to be few and far between.

Then sometimes it's just midlife issues in general.  I left both of my kids in my home town, 2500 miles away, remarried, and almost a year later my head is still spinning about this huge change in my life. I miss those kids to death, and sometimes have overwhelming feelings of guilt for having left my 12 YO.

Thanks for your post.

Hugs...Heidi

EileenG
Heidi,I'm sure that's not helping to be so far away from your kids.  It really seems like you are going through some big transitions right at the time you're going through peri- meno!  :shocked:  Bless your heart!  I know what you mean about coming to a time where Zoloft doesn't work as well.  I go between 50mg and 100mg depending on the stress in my life. (with my doctor's permission).  I also am on estradiol 1 mg now that I'm post-meno (as of March).  I think it helps -- at least somedays I do.  Mostly, I take it because my doc says women on it stay healthier in their older years.  I'm still not sure if I'll do it forever.  I had a partial hysterectomy when I was 31 so I supposedly don't need progesterone.  :confused:   Anyway,  hope you're hanging in there.  I'm glad you found this site.  the women here are just the best !  Everyone knows what it feels like to be at the end of your rope -- so, come here and share with us often.Lots of hugs,  E.
mrsmunro0510
Thanks Eileen (((((((((hugs))))))))))
ERJLG3
Hi Idie,You sound so much like me except I have been going through depression for the last 14 years since the birth of my son.  Wondering if I will ever be happy again.  I put on a pair of sunglasses any where I go.  Even in the grocerystore to hide behind them.  Despair is about all I have left.  Working with Pete at Powersurge now.  Sure hope this helps.  My last resort.  Please take care of yourself.  Didn't think that I would last 14 years.  Then the last year turned into perimenopause which is 10 times worse than depression.  Hang in there.   Jackie
HippieHeron
I am in such a deep depression now that I can't even type about it.  My husband is constantly home being sick.  It used to be every other week, now sometimes its twice a week.  Nothing that the doctors do helps.  He is probably taking more medication now than food.  I don't know how to cook anymore.  Thanksgiving is totally out.  I refuse to do all of that cooking when it probably won't be eaten.  When he suddenly takes off work because he is sick it throws our schedule off from the homeschooling.  I can't get work done.  The house is a mess.  It doesn't even feel like home anymore.  I worry about his job.  What about our financial situation if his employers get tired of this?  My daughter is depressed too, which makes me even more depressed.  I feel as tho I have totally lost my faith in  God.  Praying hasn't helped.  I've tried talking to people at this new church that I have been going to for the past year, but if I start to talk, its like they talk right over me.  Like I'm invisible or something.  I had several instances over the past year where I tried to confide my fears and my anger at the doctors to my mother, and I get lectured.  It ended up in too many fights and it is a great relief now that she and I aren't on speaking terms.  At least I'm not tempted to confide in her and receive more stress as a result.  She never considered me worth helping anyway.  Again I was good as long as I was invisible.  I ask myself, If I'm invisible, why do I live?  I know the answer.  Its for my daughter's sake.  She needs someone when she is depressed too and eventually we can find something to laugh about, no matter how short lived that enjoyment may be.   I don't even enjoy singing anymore.   I signed up for the voice lessons and they are getting me down too.  No time to practice.

  Thanks for listening everyone.  I know I've said all of this before, which makes it hard to get on the boards and keep repeating things, but this has gone on for too long.  I don't think its meno related.  I don't think that any kind of pills can help.  Maybe counseling, but where do you find a good counselor?  Probably a support group would help, but what is this classified as?  It feels like mourning.  Mourning for the life and relationships I wish that I had.  Mourning for a loss of peace of mind.  And then the mourning produces depression or anger.  And because too many people will tell you that anger is bad, it produces more depression.

       Thanks again for listening.

Gemini
Poor Ruth, you are obviously going through a very hard time. I know from things you have told us before that you have felt like this for a while, but it sounds as though now everything has come to a head.I don't know what to say to help you, but you know that we are all here for you, and will listen whenever you want to talk. Here's hoping for better times ahead for you and your family.Hugs to you (( ))
Kalanie
Hi Ruth...

I am so sorry to read that you are down again... this is really pretty pervasive stuff until we get it sorted out for ourselves, and if we do not, I am afraid it will just keep churning around inside.   sad.gif      

I am going to suggest to you again that you, your daughter, and, possibly your husband, also, get to a counselor for help in sorting this stuff out.  The best way to find a good one, of course, is to ask others who have been in any kind of counseling for a recommendation.  Of course, you can always contact a local referral network too.   And, you can always call a local hotline for help, also, and that's a 24/7 thing.

It does sound to me like you do have alot of anger going on, especially at your husband, but seem to be turning it inward on yourself,  which just results in depression and hopelessness for yourself.   And, anger, like all of our other feelings, is not a bad thing at all... when we have it, it has to get expressed, and it surely will, one way or another.  The problem with anger is that it is not expressed appropriately alot of the time, and turning it inward on yourself is just as inappropriate as taking someone's head off with it.    

Remember to take care of yourself, too, Ruth, while you are so busy taking care of all those other people and their feelings... but, most importantly of all, remember that you cannot continue to take care of others unless you can take care of yourself first.  

I will be thinking of you and hoping you will be getting yourself some help before you get too much more down on yourself.   Let me know how it goes?  :)

HippieHeron
Its hard to know how to answer this.  Thanks Beth.  I know its hard to know what to say, but I am very thankful for friends here to talk to.  I just wish that I had someone off line to rely on.  But at least I have this community.

Vickie, I don't mean this to be taken the wrong way, but I would like some information.  What good is counseling?  To me its always felt like I am paying someone money to be my friend.  I know that it is money that makes the world go around, but I would hope that love and friendship do exist somewhere (here they do at least) without a dollar sign attached to them.   And then after you've paid the money that you could have used for other things (necessities, distractions etc) the counselours give you bad advice any way.  The last thing a counselor said to me was that I should rely on my husband more.  I took the advice and immediately he got sick again.  I'm scared.  This feels like a trap.  It seems to me that the only thing that a counselor will do for you is to look at you and consider you to be a case in his textbook and give you advice based on whatever mold he feels that you fit in.       In my lifetime I have tried to help people and to be a friend to them.  To listen and give loving answers even when I didn't agree with them.  I've done that with my mother, my husband, people in the neighborhood, people at church.  But it's not returned. I know I haven't tried very hard at this new church, but the amount that I have tried hasn't worked out and I get discouraged.

    I am thankful for this website.  I am thankful for my daughter, for one of the choirs that I am in (I went last night and it was a good distraction), and thankful for some prayers that were answered at times thru the kindness of strangers.  For these reasons I don't want to lose my faith.  Altho I don't know what is happening to the rest of my world.

Kalanie
<<    In my lifetime I have tried to help people and to be a friend to them.  To listen and give loving answers even when I didn't agree with them.  I've done that with my mother, my husband, people in the neighborhood, people at church.  But it's not returned.  >>

I think this is a key clue, Ruth.  It has to do with letting people know who you really are and expressing the feelings you really have, in order to achieve some type of real intimacy for yourself in relationships with others as well as with yourself.   And, of course, it gets a little more complicated when the expectation is that it is returned.  It's really great when it is returned, but, none of us have any control over that.  :(     Also, when we focus on others and their needs, we can be successful in distracting from ourselves... our feelings, needs, problems.   The end result is that this doesn't usually fulfill people and make them feel too happy about their lives.   sad.gif    

In regard to finding a good counselor, I think a good one is one who will focus on and be brave enough to tackle the issues that bring the person to him/her.  That may not always really be what the person presents with, so some real initiative needs to be taken to, somehow, get to it.   Your perception of a counselor as a "friend" is not correct, and, if anyone has told you it is, run.  The role of a counselor is not to deal with people's issues in the same manner that people's friends do at all.  

Think about it... when we discuss a problem with a friend, they will usually sympathize and take our side, as well as reinforce our perception by giving us their own or others' similar experiences.  Just because more than one person has the same experience, though, doesn't mean it's an ok or a normal thing that isn't a problem that might need to be corrected.  It just means that several people might have the same kind of problem they need to work on.  And, rarely do people get solutions from friends.  

I don't know how many counselors you have seen, but I know few who label or categorize people.  I don't know how this counselor that you saw behaved, or what his/her training even is, so I cannot comment on that, except to say that if you feel that a counselor is not helping you or is giving you bad advice, the option you have is to find another who will.  And there are plenty out there who can and will.  But, remember that we are not all alike, just as no two people of any kind are, so be careful about labeling/categorizing counselors.  :wink:

I hope getting this information doesn't distract you for too long in seeking and getting some good counseling.   smile.gif     Don't forget to check credentials, either...  it's always really helpful if someone is specifically educated and trained in counseling, and not in another field, such as theology.  There are lots of preachers out there giving many people alot of real bad advice... my ex-husband was one of those.   sad.gif

Wordgirl
Ruth, Vickie is so right about finding a "good" therapist. I won't even add to anything she said in that vein, except that I went through a bunch of bad ones before finding a good one who TAUGHT me "right thinking," which I did not know how to do! Unfortunately, not having anyone here for eight years, I sorely need a booster shot at times (because frankly, childhood pain and old reactions never go away completely but are always waiting for the chance to knock you down).

I can share with you what I did to help myself out of a depression I had some months ago, since I have no therapist here (a method I was taught as well as studied on my own). This may not make a bit of sense to you, but here goes: I loved myself. I loved my feelings. I loved my anger. I loved my depression. I loved my hopelessness. You embrace everything. It's the hardest thing most people can do, because a lot of us see ourselves as unlovable (particularly if you didn't feel loved as a child).

It took lots of practice. I didn't love myself so I thought about how I felt when I loved my dogs (sad, huh, but back then they were all I had) and then projected that loving feeling onto myself (the actual "physical" feeling of love--it takes practice). I've mentioned this book before as a source, Learning to Love Yourself Workbook, by Gay Hendricks. Even though I had been in therapy for years, the life-long low-grade depression did not lift completely until I read and practiced those guidelines (about 15 years ago).

Of course, this will NOT transform actual problems (not your husband's health, not people talking over you, not anything outside of yourself). But it can transform YOU. When you feel better, you cope better with the husband and mother and problems. I work on myself all of the time (well, I do get lazy, but I do the work when I'm in pain!), because I still tend to automatically react to problems in an "unskilled" (O.K., I freak out)  manner due to my past scars.

My point is sometimes we have to give ourselves what we are not getting from others, whatever it is. We have to fill *ourselves* up, and, no, it is not selfish. "Do you mean I don't exist to please others? Do you mean I don't have to live up to everyone's expectations of me?" Yes, that's what I mean.

The Buddha said, "You yourself, as much as anybody in the entire Universe, deserve your love and affection." I hope what we've said here has helped or you find something that can help you. We're here for you.

Kalanie
Excellent, Wordgirl.   smile.gif
Suseyq
Ruth:  Sounds like you are going through a rough time.  As other said, this is a great place to come and let it out.  I can sympathize a bit.  I know what it is to be going through what seems like your personal hell (we had some very rough years with a teenage son).  It seems like you get hit from all sides.  And others that you look to for support (outside your immediate family) are in their little perfect world, with everything just "dandy".  They give you their "advice" and bit of support and off they go to their lives.  I think this is what life is.  Some how we get through it.  It is human nature to think it's all personal.  

As to the "counseling" issue.  Ever see the movie, "crocadile dundee"?  The part where she's telling him about seeing psychiatrists.  He says, "Don't they have any mates?"  I love that.  I do think we should have support we don't have to pay for!  I agree with Wordgirl, as to practicing "right thinking".  However, you don't have to pay a counselor to teach this to you.  There are some excellent publications out there, including my favorite, the Dali Lama.  Another, Thich Nhat Hanh.  I wish I had been on this path back then, but it wasn't the time.  Perhaps this is what this time of life is for, becoming more introspective.  Everything is a lesson, as hard as it is to take the test!

As others said, we are all here for you..

 

HippieHeron
Vickie,   I know that no counselor would call themselves a friend because they are impersonal and they would want to keep it that way if they want to be professional.  Which is basically a safe guard for those of us in the general public who might go to a counselor.  But if you are getting what might appear as good advice, a client of a counselor, might tend to think of the counselor as a friend until the light goes on  and they realize that  "hey, sure he can be a friend.  I'm good for his bank account!"   What a value that puts on the client!  "Again, I am only worth something to people if I give.  Not if I'm in need."     It's not the attitude of the counselor that is the "false friendship".  Its the attitude of me, the client.    And that's if they give good advice, which won't necessarily happen.

  You said, "Rarely do people get solutions from friends."  This is not the issue!   I am not looking for solutions from friends, I am looking for off the internet, neighborhood friends.  Period.  Not aquaintences.  Friends.   Like I've tried to be to others when they've been in need.  Like I've spent my time being to others when I could have been spending that time on myself or my daughter.   The word is loneliness.  I've got the above problems plus loneliness.   Is a counselor going to fix that?

Wordgirl, I agree with your advice on the loving ourselves book.   I have read similar books and tried to follow the advice with some success for a period of time (sometimes a longer period of success than other times) but it is hard.   Society has a myth that everyone will have many meaningful relationships.  And there is the "2 shall be as 1"  marriage myth.  And there is the "you should be of service to others" myth.   Too many traps to fall into.  But you are right about the idea that I have to give myself what I need that I'm not getting anywhere else.

Thanks SuseyQ.  I do remember that part in Crocodile Dundee.   I think that people are probably too busy and stressed to have the time for friendship in this day and society.   Probably those myths that I mentioned above wouldn't be just myths in a different time or place.   I guess I've got to accept reality, but it would be nice if the world was different.

    But Vickie, I can't throw away time and money (and hope) on bad counselors merely on the hope that I might find a good one.  I actually shouldn't have mentioned counseling in my first post.  I'm sorry if that was misleading.

(Edited by HippieHeron at 5:12 pm on Nov. 12, 2002)

chriscarol
Ruth,<br> &nbsp; &nbsp; I'm sorry to hear about your current struggles.<br>Depression can make the smallest things seem<br>insurmountable. &nbsp;Have you considered that perhaps<br>your husband is depressed? &nbsp;Melancholy is<br>sometimes manifested in hyperfocusing on<br>physical ailments. &nbsp;A good counselor could be<br>helpful. &nbsp;I know what you meant about counseling<br>being like paying for a friend. &nbsp;My husband referred to<br>my old counselor as &quot;rent a friend.&quot; &nbsp;That therapist<br>was one of the good ones. &nbsp;I've had some that were<br>down right toxic. &nbsp;Enjoy the precious moments with<br>your daughter.<p> &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp;Chris<br>being like paying for a friend. &nbsp;
GG
Ruth   I'm just trying to get a handle on something here so I need to ask you , when you are in inner pain and going through turmoil do you actually let your guard down and express to the people you are turning to that you really need their help cause you are hurting or do you just kind of mention it without really leaving yourself out there? I have a tendancy to do this cause I can't quite handle that open vulnerable feeling it's like I'd really have to expose myself and I can't do that cause you turn to me for help so how can I be so lost. I always have to put on this very together front, if this is the case than you can't be angry at people for not realizing just how much you need them. I do this to my sister sometimes I call her and let down a little bit than hang up angry cause she didn't seem to be all that helpful but I never let out all that was bothering me. Sometimes we don't know how to release all of it and that's where a good therapist is helpful. They know how to help us talk. I know people that have been fortunate enough to have found good ones and have stayed with it and are much better off for it their life isn't perfect but when rocky times hit they have been taught coping skills that they can fall back on. Also when you look at other people and they seem to be happy and moving on with their lives remember never compare your inners with their outers.Keep talking to us, we care and understand.                                GG
Suseyq
Ruth:  I just re-read my post, as well as the others.  I think we all missed the point.  You are worried about your husband, being sick, missing work, possibly losing his job.  You're plain frustrated.  Certainly none of this is your fault.  Yes, anger leads to depression, if you turn it inward.  
Kalanie
Ruth, the fact remains that we all must look inward, and no counselor is ever going to "fix" anyone.  :)

You certainly do sound very angry to me, as well as quite defended.  I spent a considerable amount of my time and energy in trying to give you a meaningful answer and trying to give you some support, while taking your questions to me as a request for information, as you said they were.  And now I do feel attacked.   Is this the way you feel when you feel you have done something nice for someone and they haven't appreciated you?  Good luck to you on feeling better someday.   smile.gif

Kalanie
Susey...  There are psychiatrists and then there are counselors... quite a difference between them.  :)  Was that supposed to be like a lawyer joke????
Gemini
Ruth, hoping today is a little happier for you. We are all here for you smile.gif
HippieHeron
I am only going to say one more thing on the topic of going to a counselor.  One of my major problems is time.  I am stressed because I have too much to do with too little time to do it.  My schedule keeps getting thrown off by my husband's illness.  This is the last year of homeschooling for my daughter.  We've got a lot of work to do because I'm concerned about her being ready for high school.  Part of the reason that the house does not feel like my home is that it is a dump and I'm the one who has to clean it.  Scheduling in a counselor appointment (possibly with a bad counselor) would be the straw that broke the camels back.  And it conjurs up memories of  the jerk that I last  saw and I can't imagine myself wasting precious time on that.  Besides, what good have professionals done for my husband?  (I mean doctors in this case)  He has a doctors appt once a week and he's just getting worse.  If my honesty on this topic offends anyone, I'm sorry.  But I also don't have the time to debate this issue.
IreneCrites
Good morning Ruth...at least I hope you can see through the fog of pain to acknowledge that every morning is a good one.  I have read and reread the postings here from yourself and your Power Surge friends and am not sure I can add any suggestions that have not already been offered to you.

I guess I would be bunched together as one of those "counselors" yuk!!! that you have been so frustrated with Ruth. smile.gif  I hope that I never make any of my clients feel like I am just there to smile, nod and give bad advice for 50 minutes so they will pay me.As far as getting paid for a service that one provides it has no bearing on their level of professional & personal committment to their client.  As in all areas of life different individuals bring different energies, commitment, values and agendas with them as part of their "baggage".  We see it in the cashier at a supermarket, sales associates in the stores we frequent,  mechanics, plumbers, etc.....I'm sure you get my point.  The complication to this fact is that everyone feels (and I agree) that counselors, physicians, nurses, lawyers, clergy should be above reproach in all areas.  In a perfect world that would be the case, but this is not a perfect world so imperfect beings find their way into every profession including "counselors".However not ALL couselors/therapists come from a place of selfishness and greed.  I'm sure that when you work you expect to be paid for your services and well you should....so the same with counselors.  The fact that some may not be worth yours or anyone elses money is a totally separate matter.  I agree with the women who have advised you to use a referral system in searching for a credible, reputable counselor.  That is the most effective, prudent way to weed through some not so worthy practitioners.  It does sound to me, in really reading between the lines of your postings, that life has become so overwhelmingly sad for you right now that just the thought of researching for a good therapist feels daunting when coupled with all the other struggles you are going through.  

I think that SusyQ has posed a vialble suggestion in that your husband's physical symptoms could be directly related to his underlying depression.  Perhaps he could discuss this with the physician that is prescribing all the medication he is taking or even better maybe he could get a second opinion.

As far as Vickie's advice through the course of many postings I feel it has been offered with caring/loving thought and to continuely rebuff her commitment to you leads me to sense that perhaps your just too down and angry for message board support to be the best avenue for you right now. It would appear that although nurturing and honoring to you, you need more right now than friendly suggestions.  Goodness knows the women on this thread have tried....but it would appear to no avail in spite of their continued efforts so although we can be here to offer you support and all want to continue to do that, as we all care about how you are feeling,  it would seem that some advice from your physician would be a good direction to start with.  We can do alot here on the Power Surge message boards but we are not therapists...this forum is not designed to diagnose or treat but to be of comfort and support.  If you, as you have posted, do not have any friends in your community you sure have them here.  My concern is that in your sadness/anger you are turning folks away from you, as was mentioned in an earlier posting, without even being aware that you are doing it.  We do try to sheild ourselves from pain in many creative ways...perhaps your way is to let people in only so far.  If that is the case its very difficult as a "concerned" person to know what to do to help and yet I sense you are caught in a quagmire. sad.gif

The fact that you have posted that your husband is physically ill and finding going to work more and more difficult, your daughter is depressed and you are so overwhelmed would indicate perhaps something, very pervasive is going on within your family dynamics and considering family therapy as well as individual therapy for each of you might be advantageous.   Just a thought. smile.gif

I do "Life Coach Counseling" and work with individuals as well as families and I feel that the right therapist could be very helpful to all of you.  I hope you find the inner strength/energy to try to find a caring & compassionate professional to work with, as you all deserve the quality of life that the Universe intended for each of us.  Please keep posting and let us know how it is going for you and your family......just try to take one day at a time and think sunshine even if for one brief moment each day to start...eventually with the right help and support all your days will be sunny.  At least that is my wish for you today and everyday.  I send you healing energy and love Ruth. Please be well. smile.gif

Ladies I commend you on your ongoing "being there" for each other.  I am honored to be apart of you.

Blessings and be well.

HippieHeron
From here I'm going back to replying to other posts.

Chriscarol, I know what you mean.  I've contemplated that this illness of his might be depression related too, but at this point I know that he has to make decisions about that, I can't do it for him.  I'm going to focus on taking care of myself and my daughter.  That is also one of the problems.  I always have felt in this relationship that I was the one expected to make all of the decisions, especially if they involved anything emotional.  This burden is getting old too.

Thanks again for your replies, Beth and SuseyQ. smile.gif

debrikkia
This may sound very simple, but through my own experiences, and those of some close friends, I've found one true thing that helps to pull me up from the bottom, and it's not an easy thing to do when you're SO far down.  It is simply this....I concentrate on a friend, family member, whoever--who is having a rough time and I reach out to them, pray for them, support them--whatever they need.  This truly takes my mind off myself, and before I know it, I'm feeling better too.Debbi
Wordgirl
"I think we all missed the point.  You are worried about your husband, being sick, missing work, possibly losing his job.  You're plain frustrated" (Suseyq)

Suseyq, I can't speak for anyone else, but I didn't address the "husband" issue because that is pointless, in my opinion. We can't change others. He has seen doctors. Most likely Ruth has expressed her feelings about the situation. He probably knows there is a problem. Also not changeable is whether he will lose his job or not (only he can do this). Therefore, I only addressed what worked for me during depressions, as you can only change yourself (such as helping yourself to release the anger, frustration, etc.). She already knows what her options are with regard to him. He can be supported, of course, but he will ultimately decide what he does or does not do. Maybe he has an undetected medical problem, I don't know. As for friends who take your support and give nothing back, you'll never change them either. The best we can do is change our *outlook* on things.

On the other hand, if Ruth just wanted to vent here and get support, there's nothing wrong with that and it does help. I have *some* of the same problems Ruth has (no friends where we live now AT ALL, as I've so far just met major "takers" only interested in themselves, no family I speak to, and a mother who never has the slightest interest in me) so I think I can understand some, though not all, of the frustration she is going through. We all want to help each other here, because we can usually relate to each other's pain.

The great thing (about posting) is you get to hear everyone's opinion and you just might hear something that will work for you. Take what you want, ignore the rest. I know everyone meant well. I responded because Ruth is such a loving, caring person, which is evident from her posts.

(Edited by Wordgirl at 4:15 pm on Nov. 13, 2002)

GG
Ruth    Thought about you alot today. I don't have any answers and I really don't have any advice but I want you to know I'm thinking about you and wishing I could come up with the solution that would make you feel so much better. Keep talking to us give us a chance . We do care.                        GG
IreneCrites
Kudos to you Wordgirl for such an insightful post.  You are so right in that we can all learn something new just by reading the posts, taking what we can use and let the rest go.  You are also correct that we can only change ourselves and our outlook....everyone has to do that for themselves.  In our eagerness to help perhaps we inundated Ruth with "free advice" when all she needed was to vent and us to listen.

Thanks for such a simple, forthright suggestion to get us back on track.

Blessings and be well.  

Kalanie
I just have a couple of things to say before I abandon this thread completely:

<<  Vickie, I don't mean this to be taken the wrong way, but I would like some information.  What good is counseling? >>

I feel pretty set up and baited by this statement from you, Ruth, because, as it turns out, it was used to elicit a response from me that was turned against me in a most abusive and hurtful way, especially considering the fact that I am, by profession,  a marriage/family and child counselor, a fact pretty well known by many women here at PS.  Ruth, I sincerely do hope that you will be able to sort through all of your issues, and your intense anger will soon subside.

<<  We can do alot here on the Power Surge message boards but we are not therapists...this forum is not designed to diagnose or treat but to be of comfort and support. >>

Irene, I think this is an excellent and insightful statement you have made here.  :)   Though I am, indeed, a therapist, I am all too aware of the fact that diagnoses and treatment are impossible and totally inappropriate in this type of forum, as you also suggest.  For that, as well as a host of other reasons, I pretty much usually totally refrain from doing so here.  I feel like I went way past my own comfort zone to even go as far as I did in responding to that request for information about counseling and counselors, but chose to take the question as presented, to be just a request for information, not to be taken "the wrong way".   Thank you, Irene.

Seti
May I back up a moment and thank Wordgirl for her sublime post of 11/12/02?  It speaks to me loud and clear.
debrikkia
I'm saddened by the angst that I feel in this thread--maybe we need a new topic?  Sometimes people just need a place to go where they can just "come undone".  If you are alone in your home and you can find the time to yell and make your voice known...  DO it!  If you have a full time job, and then come home to a family--then you need to find or make a time when you can vent.  If you're never alone and you want to scream and yell and tell the world how you feel..........then we need to create another topic where we can go to do that!!   One place where we can just voice our opinion, say how we feel, leave it there and go to bed!  No comments, no advice, no  "here's what I think"......just a place where we can "type" what we're feeling, and leave it at that--just to get it OUT.  What do you think?  Maybe we should ask Dearest.
MaryO
QUOTE
If you're never alone and you want to scream and yell and tell the world how you feel..........then we need to create another topic where we can go to do that!!   One place where we can just voice our opinion, say how we feel, leave it there and go to bed!  No comments, no advice, no  "here's what I think"......just a place where we can "type" what we're feeling, and leave it at that--just to get it OUT.  What do you think?
I, too, am disheartened by the dischord that been going on in here these last few days.  Unfortunately, no matter how much we post, or read, we can never truly know what another person is going through, what the extenuating circumstances are, what the hormones are doing.  All we really have to work with are what others tell us...and that's not always a true picture, anyway.  But it's late, and I digress smile.gif

What I wanted to say is I don't think that a topic like that would work.  Invariably, someone would come along who would want to comment...and she would.  Then the original poster wouldn't feel safe posting in that way anymore.

Also, the whole point of message boards is to get the support and opinions of many people.  When I'm down, hurt, depressed, angry (most of the time!  LOL)  I often write an email to the person(s), if any.  

I spend quite a lot of time on this email, getting the wording right, rearranging the paragraphs (that's why computers are better than paper), getting it absolutely perfect.  It works out some of my frustrations, but I never send it.  Sometimes, I'll delete it, but usually, I'll save for the next time - because I know that there's always going to be a next time, unfortunately.

This solution is probably a pretty lame one, but it works for me.

I'd like to offer hugs and support to anyone who felt hurt and/or misunderstood in this thread.  Online can be a very tricky thing sometimes.  But it's the best we have for now smile.gif

Dearest
I'm in the middle of sending out the announcements for tonight's chats (yes, I do this at 2:30 in the morning - talk about needing counselling) when an IM brought this thread to my attention (she probably needs couselling, too). I will read it later and plan to comment, but I have a few more thousand announcements to send out (needing head examined).

Be back after my mailings - try to remember we're all sisters and in this together and that we're all different and have different viewpoints.

And, Ruth, know that we all love you and everyone seems to be trying very hard to help you in whatever way they can with whatever means they have. That's all we can do here anyway - is to share.

Be back soon to write my response.

Dearest

Wordgirl
Mary, that is not lame at all, it's a great idea! It has been proven that writing about problems (or typing), even if no one ever reads it, is theraputic.

A recent Texas A&M study had college students write for 20 minutes (about a tramatic or an unemotional topic) and then e-mail them to researchers. Their subsequent health surveys found that people who shared their problems were sick less often and missed fewer classes than the people who explored neutral subjects. It also said that unbeknownst to the writers, though, no one ever even read their emails. So this worked even with no feedback. In fact, it advises us to achieve these benefits by writing and then hit the delete button!

Anyway, I hope the one misunderstanding here doesn't turn anyone off to venting their feelings. If they truly don't want feedback, they might try the technique above.

Dearest
I think lots of people have provided lots of very caring and informative responses to your issues, Ruth, and those issues aren't simple to cope with. Depression has a very insidious nature. We can't always pinpoint what the specific causes are. Couple that with being menopausal -- when everything is exacerbated by our hormonal issues -- it's virtually impossible to know if menopause, itself, is causing our depression, or if life's events, separate and apart from menopause are contributing. I've said so many times that menopause doesn't happen in a vacuum -- that everything is connected. That when people come onto this site talking about serious marital problems, family issues and various and sundry other problems, they more frequently than not were problematic before menopause set in. What happens during menopause is that the you know what hits the fan. Suddenly, not only are we faced with having to cope with all the problems we brought into menopause, but we have to cope with the myriad of symptoms that menopause brings.

Menopause is unkind. It hasn't a sense of decency to it whatsoever. It afflicts every woman regardless of her lot in life. It's merciless, thoughtless, and a constant challenge.

Ruth, your messages convey what you think is causing your depression. From what I've read, it appears to me that the depression is the result of a combination of issues. You're overwhelmed. By your husband's health situation. By how it's affecting your relationship. By how it's affecting his health. By the impact it's having on everything. By the potential impact it could have on his work. By how that might affect your economic situation. You're overwhelmed by your children, wonderful as they may be. When one is depressed and under stress, everything is overwhelming. There's the additional stress of home schooling, the tedium of cleaning, the general "not-having-a-moment-to-breathe" syndrome.

How could all this NOT emotionally wear down even the strongest person?  

How could it NOT make anyone angry, depressed, frustrated, overwhelmed and, sometimes, ready to throw in the towel?

Nothing you've expressed could have anyone reading it think for a single moment that you weren't totally justified in feeling as you do.

As for counselling, aka therapy and therapists, I agree and disagree. I think at times in our lives we may be receptive to therapy. At other times, we may not. I think when we've found a good therapist, we're proponents of therapy. When we've had bad experiences with therapists, we think therapy's a waste of time, too costly and, as you said, the monies spent could be enjoyed elsewhere - then again, how can you enjoy spending the money elsewhere if you never resolve the problems that are causing the depression, the anger, the frustration -- if you don't get your life in order. You can't.

I've had similar experiences with therapists as you, and others on this board, have. Remember how sick I was earlier this year and how it's lasted for months? I'm still not myself (and this is not to turn the conversation around to myself - I'm trying to make an important point using myself as an example). I became so overwhelmed by that experience and by reliving an experience of 15 years ago when I was told by doctors, oncologists, everyone -- that I was dying of liver cancer (which, obviously I wasn't). After the worst part of this year's illness passed, my anxiety levels soared, and I already had enough anxiety for two people. In the past, my experiences with therapists have been nightmares. I felt just as you did. I wouldn't waste a dime on one of them. . . until I realized I had to get myself and my anxiety in order, and get to the underlying reasons for what I was feeling because it wasn't simply from being sick. I knew I had to find someone objective to talk to. Not to a friend. Not to a family member. Not to friends I have online. I had to come face to face with my demons -- with everything in the past that had brought me to this present. So, I began a journey through about 5-6 therapists including psychiatrists who only wanted to prescribe medication and not "talk" to me. Less than two months ago, I found a woman with whom I can relate on so many levels, someone who listens, someone who talks, someone who has even had some of the horrible experiences I have and who has shared them with me. Someone who cares and someone who has helped me more than any other therapist I have ever tried. Someone who was "worth" it.

Because I have found the "right person," I have a renewed faith in therapy.

Friends you have in the real world, online, or anywhere don't have the expertise a good therapist has. Friends may have the best intentions in the world, may be the most decent human beings you know, may hold your hand in your moments of crisis, may offer advice on how to cope with your problems, BUT when you're suffering from problems that are adversely affecting your entire quality of life, that are so overwhelming that you don't know which way to turn, you need someone professional who knows how to draw out the venom from the snake bites.

Ruth, you always come across as a fine and decent woman. Look at all the people here who are concerned about you -- oh, you may think they're just "online" people, but they're still "people" -- there are real human beings behind the monitors and keyboards - people who've experienced their own sufferings.

I think, despite how far we've come in the area of mental health, there's still a stigma attached to "going to a therapist." There shouldn't be. We take vitamins to make our bodies healthy. We take insulin if we have diabetes. We use various products to treat our physical menopause symptoms.

Our psyches, emotions and spirits are as impacted by menopause as is our physical person -- and it's imperative that we treat our minds with the same care and respect we do our bodies.

Whatever you decide to do regarding your situation, it's clearly your decision. However, those who have suggested counselling are well aware of the benefits you can derive from some form of professional communication.

You may choose to wait it out and see if this "worst" time passes, but the depression is likely to continue to gnaw at you, at your spirit and your soul until you resolve the issues that are causing it.

I hope and pray that whatever path you decide to take, that you will get better.

Now --  I have to go from this to preparing for a chat about vaginas. Isn't life silly? :biggrin:

Warm hugs to you, Ruth.

Dearest

MaryO
QUOTE
Remember how sick I was earlier this year and how it's lasted for months? I'm still not myself (and this is not to turn the conversation around to myself - I'm trying to make an important point using myself as an example). I became so overwhelmed by that experience and by reliving an experience of 15 years ago when I was told by doctors, oncologists, everyone -- that I was dying of liver cancer (which, obviously I wasn't).
I know that you didn't intend to turn this post into something about you, Dearest, but every time I read about this experience with the "liver cancer" I get so angry at these doctors who could misdiagnose you like that.  Just makes my blood boil.

Thank goodness they were all wrong!

I'm glad that you've found a good therapist, too, one that you can work with.  That must be such a wonderful thing, to be able to discuss whatever with someone so understanding and helpful.

As one of those who has never had much luck with counselors - sometimes my own fault, because I'd refuse to talk! - in many ways I envy you this experience.  I suspect that I'm going to take whatever mental baggage I have with me to the grave - and just pray that I haven't passed it on to the next generation.

Dearest
You don't have to envy my finding a good therapist, Mary. If and when you're ready, you can do anything you want to do. You just really have to be ready. It's not unlike losing weight. It's a very personal decision and when we're receptive, things work. When we're not, we're in limbo. I'm uncomfortable with things that don't get resolved and have always known that I'm not very good at accepting those things I can't change. It has its positive aspects, but it also has its drawbacks as it can prevent one from moving forward while dwelling on trying to fix problems with other people that aren't fixable.  

My blood boils, too, when I think of what you went through before your Cushings was diagnosed -- with doctors giving you tranquilizers, being told "this, too, shall pass" and nobody knowing you had a brain tumor or Cushings until you took matters into your own hands and went to NIH. Just keep telling yourself, Mary, that you can do anything you set your mind to. I, as a friend, know that you can.

Incidentally, my therapist is out of my HMO's network, but is so far superior to anyone I saw in network that I'm willing to foot the bill myself - I pay over $4,000.00 a year for my own health coverage and am entitled to a certain amount of annual therapy visits, but they won't cover her because she doesn't accept HIP and at her age (she's semi-retired) doesn't want to become involved with them.

Incidentally, your suggestion above wasn't lame at all. I do it all the time. I've got more E.mails I've never sent, more letters I've never mailed, but managed to work through many feelings of frustration and anger by writing them down.

Dearest

Dearest
I also want to add something about the discord that grew from Ruth's original message. My purpose in responding was simply to address Ruth's issues. My purpose on these boards is not to become embroiled in discord, but, rather, to diffuse situations that get out of hand.

I'm not here to take sides, but I did mention in my original message that it was apparent that many people were trying to help Ruth with her depression. I found nothing offensive in Vickie's messages. In fact, as usual, Vickie went above and beyond the call of duty in trying to help someone in distress and help Ruth address her issues. I don't prefer to comment on Ruth's reaction and then Vickie's response -- yada, yada. I would hope by now that everyone on these boards knows that Vickie (Kalanie) always comes from a "good place" and the information she provided in this thread was not only caring and with concern, but more importantly, from someone with expertise in the area of therapy.

I don't like to see arguing among members. That's not what we're here for. We're here to help one another. From what I see from reading all the responses to Ruth's cries for help, everyone did just that.

Dearest

HippieHeron
The mistake was mine.  I shouldn't have posted to begin with.  I did it out of loneliness.  I remember one time, before a friend of mine moved away, I needed someone to talk to and we went out for coffee.  That conversation had a good feeling to it and I thought that coming here with this problem could also have that good feeling.  But I did learn from my mistake.

    A few years ago, when I was in similar, but worse situations, I attended a discussion group on a book called "You can Heal Your Life"  Part of that book discussed the problem of all of the Shoulds that we are bombarded with in life.  "You should do this, you should do that etc"  and we tend to repeat them back to ourselves, like all that we have ever heard keeps re-echoing in our minds, especially when we are stressed.  That's what I heard here:  "You should go to counseling, you should find a friend to help so you forget about your problems".  My major problem is stress, because of lack of time to do the things I want to do:  Homeschool my daughter, make a more pleasant home for myself and her, pursue a couple of interests of my own.  I don't have time for counseling, or for debating about it.  I also don't have time for feeling guilty about "Shoulds".  "Shoulds" that others tell me or "Shoulds" that I remember and tell myself.  So thank you for helping me to see that.  Now I'm going to go and do what I want to do.  smile.gif

   I am glad that you are feeling better, Dearest.  That is good news.  smile.gif

(Edited by HippieHeron at 12:02 pm on Nov. 15, 2002)

MaryO
QUOTE
The mistake was mine.  I shouldn't have posted to begin with.  I did it out of loneliness.  I remember one time, before a friend of mine moved away, I needed someone to talk to and we went out for coffee.  That conversation had a good feeling to it and I thought that coming here with this problem could also have that good feeling.  But I did learn from my mistake.
I don't think that anyone told you what you should do Ruth - they were mainly offering things that have worked for them.  No one here can tell anyone else what they should - or should not - do.  None of us has all the information needed to do that.  And, certainly no one wants you to add guilt onto your depression.

I hope that you feel better soon, doing what *you* want to do,

Wordgirl
MaryO, I didn't see any "shoulds" either. I stated very clearly, "this is what has helped me." And I thank Vickie and Irene and Seti for the compliments.

Sometimes we feel so much pressure that we interpret what other people say as "shoulds" and just more pressure, perhaps?

Every time I read of Dearest's health problems, I am shocked all over again (particularly the misdiagnosis). You must have incredible strength, Dearest. It's almost unimaginable to me how you coped. But, thank God you did, or a lot of us would be doing a lot worse than we are now.

Dearest
Some time back, I walked into Macy's dressing room, minding my own business, getting ready to try on some clothes. A woman walked up to me (before I had a chance to stop her) and said she was going to an afternoon wedding and asked if I liked the dress she had on. I really don't like when people ask my opinion unless it's a good friend who I know wants to hear my answer. I said to the woman, "If you're asking my opinion, I'll have to be honest." She said, "Of course, be honest." I said, "I don't think it's  flattering. I think you could find something that fits better and looks more suitable for the occasion." She started giving me an argument, like .. "What do you know?" I said to her, "Lady, let me give you a piece of advice. Don't ask for someone's opinion if you only want them to tell you what you want to hear."

Ruth, I don't know if you're aware of it because I've never seen you this way, but while you are reaching out to people, you are closing out those people at the same time. If you look through my very long response, I don't use the word "should" even once. In fact, the only time any form of the word appears in my post, it is "shouldn't" not "should" -- as in "I think, despite how far we've come in the area of mental health, there's still a stigma attached to "going to a therapist. There shouldn't be."  

Thank you, Ruth, for your good wishes re my health. I do hope you feel better, too.

Dearest

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.